Money-market fund reforms proposed by the rapporteur for a European Parliamentary committee would provide some leeway for funds to continue operating under a stable-valuation model, but would still lead to a significant shake-up of the sector in Europe, Fitch Ratings says.
The proposed rules would probably drive some outflows as corporate treasurers accustomed to constant net asset value (CNAV) funds would look for alternative places to park their cash. However, we believe the impact may not be as dramatic as some participants initially feared, as a Fitch poll shows many investors won't change their strategy and because alternatives are limited.
Some investors, particularly those that are unwilling to accept the small fluctuations in value of variable net asset value (VNAV) funds, will look for alternatives. However a poll of attendees at a Fitch conference on cash management in November suggested that investors may be getting more comfortable with the idea of VNAV. In the poll, 57% of respondents said their allocation to MMFs would stay the same and 43% said it would fall if the market moved to a CNAV model. At the same conference a year earlier, 75% of participants said they would cut MMF holdings if VNAV were introduced.
The proposed regulation, which is due to be debated by the parliament's Committee on Economic and Monetary Affairs, is an amended version of the European Commission's original text. The main changes include allowing some MMFs that invest mainly in EU public debt or which are only available to retail investors, public authorities and non-profit organisations to continue to operate as constant net asset value funds without the need for a 3% capital buffer. The European Council is also reviewing the Commission's original text and will propose its own amendments.
Retail investors are a small part of the European CNAV investor base and government debt funds account for no more than 12%, but the proposed exemption closely mirrors US reform, as does the ability of funds to apply liquidity fees and redemption restrictions in times of market stress.
Similar regimes in the US and Europe could make it easier for large multi-national corporations to manage liquidity centrally. But the reforms would still require major operational changes from investors that currently rely on CNAV funds, as most funds would have to switch to a VNAV model. The accounting treatment of these holdings is unclear.
The potential for corporate treasures to make the switch is supported by VNAV funds being already common in a few European markets, particularly France and the Benelux countries. Investors will continue to have access to CNAV public-sector focussed MMFs and bank deposits, although there may be capacity constraints with public sector MMFs and bank wholesale deposits are less attractive under Basel III.
Fitch Ratings Limited
fitchratings.com
The proposed rules would probably drive some outflows as corporate treasurers accustomed to constant net asset value (CNAV) funds would look for alternative places to park their cash. However, we believe the impact may not be as dramatic as some participants initially feared, as a Fitch poll shows many investors won't change their strategy and because alternatives are limited.
Some investors, particularly those that are unwilling to accept the small fluctuations in value of variable net asset value (VNAV) funds, will look for alternatives. However a poll of attendees at a Fitch conference on cash management in November suggested that investors may be getting more comfortable with the idea of VNAV. In the poll, 57% of respondents said their allocation to MMFs would stay the same and 43% said it would fall if the market moved to a CNAV model. At the same conference a year earlier, 75% of participants said they would cut MMF holdings if VNAV were introduced.
The proposed regulation, which is due to be debated by the parliament's Committee on Economic and Monetary Affairs, is an amended version of the European Commission's original text. The main changes include allowing some MMFs that invest mainly in EU public debt or which are only available to retail investors, public authorities and non-profit organisations to continue to operate as constant net asset value funds without the need for a 3% capital buffer. The European Council is also reviewing the Commission's original text and will propose its own amendments.
Retail investors are a small part of the European CNAV investor base and government debt funds account for no more than 12%, but the proposed exemption closely mirrors US reform, as does the ability of funds to apply liquidity fees and redemption restrictions in times of market stress.
Similar regimes in the US and Europe could make it easier for large multi-national corporations to manage liquidity centrally. But the reforms would still require major operational changes from investors that currently rely on CNAV funds, as most funds would have to switch to a VNAV model. The accounting treatment of these holdings is unclear.
The potential for corporate treasures to make the switch is supported by VNAV funds being already common in a few European markets, particularly France and the Benelux countries. Investors will continue to have access to CNAV public-sector focussed MMFs and bank deposits, although there may be capacity constraints with public sector MMFs and bank wholesale deposits are less attractive under Basel III.
Fitch Ratings Limited
fitchratings.com
Les médias du groupe Finyear
Chaque jour (5j/7) lisez gratuitement :
Le quotidien Finyear :
- Finyear Quotidien
La newsletter quotidienne :
- Finyear Newsletter
Recevez chaque matin par mail la newsletter Finyear, une sélection quotidienne des meilleures infos et expertises de la finance d’entreprise et de la finance d'affaires.
Chaque mois lisez gratuitement :
Le magazine digital :
- Finyear Magazine
Les 6 lettres digitales :
- Le Directeur Financier
- Le Trésorier
- Le Credit Manager
- Le Capital Investisseur
- GRC Manager
- Le Contrôleur de Gestion (PROJET 2014)
Un seul formulaire d'abonnement pour recevoir un avis de publication pour une ou plusieurs lettres
Le quotidien Finyear :
- Finyear Quotidien
La newsletter quotidienne :
- Finyear Newsletter
Recevez chaque matin par mail la newsletter Finyear, une sélection quotidienne des meilleures infos et expertises de la finance d’entreprise et de la finance d'affaires.
Chaque mois lisez gratuitement :
Le magazine digital :
- Finyear Magazine
Les 6 lettres digitales :
- Le Directeur Financier
- Le Trésorier
- Le Credit Manager
- Le Capital Investisseur
- GRC Manager
- Le Contrôleur de Gestion (PROJET 2014)
Un seul formulaire d'abonnement pour recevoir un avis de publication pour une ou plusieurs lettres
Autres articles
-
Entretien | Mark Kepeneghian, Kriptown. "J'ai toujours eu comme projet de trouver un moyen d'aider à financer l'économie réelle"
-
Nomination | F3P, Marie Guillemot, Présidente du Directoire de KPMG devient la Présidente de la Fédération Française des Firmes Pluridisciplinaires
-
DeluPay déploie sa solution de paiement auprès du Paris FC
-
Powens, Bertrand Jeannet quitte ses fonctions exécutives, Jean Guillaume, ex-Xpollens devient CEO
-
Fintech R:EVOLUTION... C'est dans une semaine !