Corporate Finance News

Mercredi 11 Mai 2016

Blockchain in Banking: Disruptive Threat or Tool? (Morgan Stanley)

Blockchains could have widespread potential to disrupt financial intermediaries. Our in-depth study suggests several misconceptions & identifies 10 hurdles to overcome to make blockchain a reality in banking. The opportunity is clear but the blue sky is too far off to impact our 2017/18e.

The pot of gold? Higher efficiencies

It's early days, but industry heavyweights are sponsoring a wide range of blockchain use cases supported by industry consortiums. As NIM fades and capital builds, global bank managements press harder for a step down in costs. Cost mutualisation through blockchain architected financial system utilities could provide some earnings boost after the related multi-year investment spend plateaus.

But blockchains could be a double-edged sword and disrupt financials

Blockchains won't just change the Financial Services' IT architecture. They could also change accessible profit pools. A lot will depend on the governance and how quickly incumbents move. The firms holding the keys to the data and the IT architecture could drive more profit pool towards themselves. So it's no wonder that the custodians like JPM, BK and STT are among the lead sponsors of Linux Hyperledger and are members of R3 as they seek to drive the standard and retain their ground.

The market underestimates the advantages banks and custodians have already, given not a single policymaker we met with for this note would allow an "unpermissioned" distributed ledger

Nor would the banks, given concerns on AML and KYC. As a result, we think industry supported consortia rather than VC sponsored start-ups will have the edge.

10 roadblocks for blockchains to become a reality in banking:
1) is the use case cost/benefit compelling?,
2) cost mutualisation/who funds the overhaul old systems?,
3) misaligned incentives,
4) evolving to the right standard,
5) scaleability/performance,
6) governance,
7) regulatory issues,
8) legal risks,
9) cryptology/security, and
10) simplicity/interoperability.

What's the best use case?

The majority of ideas hinge on reducing inefficiencies in capital markets infrastructure. Several industry leaders including Blythe Masters (CEO of Digital Asset Holdings – see conversation later in this note) put post-trade settlement for a variety of asset classes at the top of the list. Domestic payments is already efficient, especially with real-time pay in much of EU/UK and coming to the US, but some believe international payments could benefit from a blockchain-type communication protocol.

While the long-term opportunity is clear, the blue sky is still too far to the right to affect 2017/18 EPS, we think, so our stock positioning generally reflects medium-term earnings issues for our banks.

Download below this Morgan Stanley report.

Pour lire tous les articles Finyear dédiés Blockchain rendez-vous sur

Participez aux conférences Blockchain éditées par Finyear :
Blockchain Pitch Day#1 (10 mai 2016)
Blockchain Vision #4 ( 7 juin 2016)
Blockchain Hackathon #1 (octobre 2016)

Finyear est partenaire média de France Blocktech, l'association française de l'écosystème blockchain.

Les médias du groupe Finyear

Lisez gratuitement :

Le quotidien Finyear :
- Finyear Quotidien

La newsletter quotidienne :
- Finyear Newsletter
Recevez chaque matin par mail la newsletter Finyear, une sélection quotidienne des meilleures infos et expertises en Finance innovation, Blockchain révolution & Digital transformation.

Les 6 lettres mensuelles digitales :
- Le Directeur Financier
- Le Trésorier
- Le Credit Manager
- The Chief FinTech Officer
- The Chief Blockchain Officer
- The Chief Digital Officer

Le magazine trimestriel digital :
- Finyear Magazine

Un seul formulaire d'abonnement pour recevoir un avis de publication pour une ou plusieurs lettres